Not just one day, my better half suggested going for a stroller and I personally wanted to go for a baby carrier, this discussion went on for many days. The comfort and warmth I can give to my baby with a baby carrier encourage me to go for it.
In the same way, John looked for my comfort and convenience, he always looked for a stroller.
So in all these years, we have used both baby carriers and strollers. In both cases there are many comforts and positives to talk about and same way demerits too.
Here in this article, with all my experience together, I will talk about a stroller vs a baby carrier. You can explore all the ups and downs of both, and finally, in the end, I will definitely try to help you out in deciding what to buy between them.
Browse this Post
Things about Stroller
Same like every other story, I had many discussions and experimented a lot on what to buy to carry my child. Finally, I came to the stroller, I actually tried different types of strollers too in order to make my child and me more comfortable.
But that’s also another struggle to find the right one for you and your baby. Anyways after purchasing the stroller, in fact, I feel like my life has become somewhat easy. There are many pluses with strollers and of course some negatives too.
With my overall stroller experience, I would tell all the sides of the coin in detail.
Overall Plus Things About a Stroller
- Convenience
Stroller allowed me to take my baby for a long time. It helped me in easy traveling and easy carrying. It helps you in moving and you can even stay anywhere by keeping your baby in a stroller safely.
The mobility and freedom that a stroller provides is the best thing about the stroller. Storage, comfort, versatility, and easy transportation, folding all together make it more convenient.
2. Comfort
Strollers come with the most comfortable options. It has adjusted backrests and padded seats for the utmost comfort for the baby. The most comfortable seating can be provided to the child without any worry.
When it’s about comfort, it’s a lot more comfortable for the parent as well. Multiple times when no one is there to help me out, I used to end up with a heavy pack of pain by carrying the whole day.
With a stroller, it helps in providing the parent with more comfort and easy navigation. If it’s a vacation, all your time would end up carrying the baby if not a stroller.
Related: Why Do Babies Sleep Better In Stroller
3. Better Interaction
Keeping in a stroller almost helps you in relieving most of the stress about carrying a baby. If you are carrying, you can just talk but it would be a little burden to interact with the child more.
If you rest your baby in the stroller, you can show things better to your child, sing a song or make them laugh easily.
4. Storage
Taking care of a baby means always running for things, once for diapers, another for milk or food, and another run for something else. But in the stroller, you can find an organized space for keeping your baby’s needs.
You can keep all the napkins, food, toys, medicines, and every other in the stroller inside the organized compartments. Though it comes at a different price, but stroller with storage actually helps you alot and decreases your burden.
5. Durability
Recently my cousin called and they are happy about the stroller they received. That was actually the first stroller John purchased. We maintained and took care of it well. After a few months, when our child was a little grown-up, I gave it to my cousin.
Again my cousin also did the same and gave it back to another cousin. So you can understand if you can invest in a good quality stroller, it would be strong enough and durable too that can be passed on from one to another.
6. Multi-Serving
Stroller serves a lot of purposes to the child as you can travel with it, keep the baby rested, and can store their basic needs in it. There are other options too.
It gives your child nice protection and a space for a good sleep too if required. So the stroller basically covers the baby’s needs.
The low sides of a stroller
- Heavy price
Needless to say, with all the comforts and benefits that strollers do provide, they are a little pricey. For better quality and more comfort for my baby, we spent a few dollars more too.
It starts from, depending on the adjustments, quality, and the padded material, it varies to till. With more features added to the strollers, the price also increases in direct proportion.
2. Bulkiness
Strollers have made navigation so easy. But don’t miss out on that weight and how bulky it’s. Especially when I am taking the metro or any public transportation, I can’t carry the stroller with me.
Though you can fold it down, it would be bulky and of a little weight which is not easy to carry all the time. It also consumes a lot of space wherever you take it due to its heavy size. If it’s too crowded, good luck with your chance. You can’t move forward at all.
3. Reducing touch and care
It gives you the ultimate comfort and space, but it would lose out the touch and warmth provided by the parent. Sometimes many parents keep their child in the stroller only, not remembering that it’s placing some distance between them.
Too much involvement of the child in the stroller limits learning things and exploring things better. It also regulates the growth and flexibility of the child.
4. Won’t suit the too harsh climate
Of course, the stroller comes with a nice coverage to give sufficient protection to the baby. But what about you?
Also, if it’s heavily raining or it’s a very sunny day, nothing can help you out. Stroller can give you basic protection for the baby, but it’s not welcoming to carry in critical weather, unlike other options.
5. Maintenance
A troller is simply like a machine or like a bicycle. Every week Jhon used to clean the stroller with care. It takes a lot of time and effort to clean everything and to oil the brakes and other things to function well.
You should not miss the maintenance as it would impact the movement of it.
Things About Baby Carrier
This is not a new thing at all, as we all are aware of how our mothers used to carry us. My mother used to make use of the finest clothes in our home and used to adjust me back to her while she was working.
Of course, I am not aware and haven’t seen it, but my grandfather used to say it. Even in my childhood too, I have seen many parents tying their children to them while working with different things.
Just like an updated feature of that, many more things are added to provide comfort and safety both to the child and the parent. Different types of baby carriers are available in the market based on which position and where you want to carry your baby.
Best Things About a Baby Carrier
1. Bond and closeness
The most natural thing you can expect from a baby carrier is the bond and attachment that will develop for a child towards their mother. It gives a different feel to the help and makes them more interested in knowing things by looking so closely.
2. Convenience
It used to be a tougher job to wrap up the child inside a cloth or garment and work. But with the baby carrier, it provides a nice convenience to carry and work easily. Also with these baby carriers, parents can also actually feed the baby too if required.
The weight is equally distributed in the baby carrier. It’s also very easy to remove and again wear it when it’s required.
3. Better baby health
Baby carrier increases the movement of the child along with the parent. So it also improvises the digestive system of the child a lot. Scientifically also, it reduces and avoids certain problems in the early days of growing.
It also improves the flexibility of body growth and the evolving nature of the baby. Even for the parent also, it will make them active and a good workout to the body on a regular basis.
4. Better Learning
The child will feel more active and connected to the world. In fact, I started understanding things. They will have a chance to notice whatever the parent is doing. Their brain starts thinking about it right from there.
It helps in grasping things faster. It also helps in recognizing the language and initiating the language learning process soon.
5. Travel Friendly
From a small walk to a long distance, you can easily carry your child in a baby carrier. Even in public transport you can seamlessly remove it and can wear it again easily. You can take your kid to small shopping or anywhere too with the baby carrier.
Some Negatives of a Baby Carrier
1. Size issues
While you are purchasing a baby carrier, you will purchase by analyzing and thinking about how much your baby weighs. So it won’t be suitable if your baby grows or adds more weight.
Because the baby won’t fit well in the same baby carrier, you need to change it.
2. Body strain
From a children’s perspective, it’s fine. But at the parent end, it would be fine to carry for a few hours. Beyond the time and for long carrying hours definitely affect the parent’s health and leads to issues like back pain, neck pain, and other body pains.
It also has the chance to change the body posture of the parent if carried for several hours continuously.
3. Weather issues
If it’s a hot sunny day then your body itself will be heated up and it’s not advisable or comfortable too to carry in such weather. It won’t be suitable to warm sunny days.
The baby also will feel a little difficult to breathe in warm conditions or if it’s tightly eloped.
4. Hard monitoring
Though it gives you enough support, warmth, and love, it’s hard to monitor. It’s not possible to look at each other. Especially with certain positions, you would not know whether the baby is comfortable or not.
The poor part is you can show your child by singing a song or can’t talk to them directly too.
5. Durability
Of course with the baby growing, it will no longer fit in the same. Similarly, with the usage, there would be a change in the baby carrier too. Especially with low quality, it won’t provide long durability.
It would require a regular wash to make sure it’s safe and clean out of germs. That would make the baby carrier fade out after a period.
These are the overall things about a stroller and baby carrier. This is good enough to draw out an ultra comparison table on stroller vs baby carrier.
The Ultimate Comparison for Stroller vs Baby Carrier
We have explored all the benefits and demerits and understood to some extent to stroller vs baby carrier. To make our things more organized and for better understanding, for better comparison, let’s draw out our comparison table.
| Factors | Stroller | Baby Carrier |
| Comfort | It offers a lot of comfort due to its adjustable nature and padded seats. | It’s also comforting the child offering a nice warmth and soothing the parent. |
| Storage | It has storage issues though it can be folded. It will eat up some space to store. | It doesn’t have any storage issues as it’s not bulky. |
| Convenience | Easy to navigate in open spaces but hard to manage in public and crowded places. So ideal for longer outings and small walks. | Unless worrying about carrying, it’s easy to navigate anywhere with the baby carrier, but the problem is hard to carry for a long period of time |
| Physical strain | Stroller also gives the parents a little strain on the back and shoulders if carried for a long time. | Physical strain is more if carried for a longer period, especially with heavy-weight babies. |
| Baby growth and health | Strollers actually have limited learning ways and prolonged keeping will disturb the baby’s health. | Baby carriers include a lot of movement and a chance to look closely at things. So better learning and growth |
| Price | The price depends on the material used and the features included in the stroller | It depends on the material and quality used to make the baby carrier |
| Suitability | It would be suitable mostly for infants and toddlers. | The baby carrier is basically for babies less than 3-4 years old. |
| Usage | Easy navigation throughout. Easy to fold and store as well. | The weight is equally carried throughout. It’s easy to remove and wear again. |
| Maintenance | Regular cleaning and oiling of the instruments and rollers are necessary to function well. | Cleaning and washing are required to keep it safe and neat. Still, it’s easy to clean. |
| Safety | Installed with locking mechanisms, safety breaks and others to keep the baby safe all the time. | Secure closure and, good ergonomic support will make the baby safe. |
What would I vote for in Stroller vs Baby Carrier?
So well, I have explained to you almost all the good things we need to talk about and all the downfalls we must recognize in both stroller and baby carrier. I have let you explore everything and finally, we draw a comparison table as well.
For me, I would go for the stroller because I can’t carry much. Also for me, the stroller makes me a little lighter and safer. As John could help me with regular cleaning and maintenance, I barely could bother about it.
But I also ensure to give the baby sufficient warmth and love, the comfort needed to the baby. So I don’t keep the baby in the stroller all the time. It’s just for a while, a work or a walk. I ensure the baby’s regular growth and development too.
But I know you would be asking what I would be suggesting to you in a stroller vs a baby carrier. The actual thing is it depends. You have to match it up with all the benefits and negatives I have provided.
Based on the requirements you have and the negatives you can’t carry through, you have to pick up one. Check out all the benefits and downfalls again of both. Then you should analyze which one suits you better.
FAQ
Which age a stroller and a baby carrier is suitable for?
A stroller is basically for infants and toddlers and a baby carrier is for babies less than 4 years old. In both cases, a stroller is not suitable and not safe or advisable to use for smaller babies.
In the same way, it’s hard to carry an infant or toddler through a baby carrier for a longer time.
In the baby carrier vs stroller, which one is more efficient?
It’s actually a hard thing to determine which one is more efficient. A stroller looks a little more effective than a baby carrier due to its features. However, both are having their advantages and disadvantages.
So it’s hard to determine which one is more efficient. When it comes to choosing, you need to choose as per your requirements and balances.
Conclusion
So, guys, we are finally at the end after a deep analysis and going through multiple things on stroller vs carrier. We looked at all the benefits and the demerits of both the stroller and baby carrier.
We have also seen the comparison between a stroller vs baby carrier. Hope you get the differences easily with that.
Hope you understand things well. I gave from my experience and chose based on my requirements. So I also would recommend you the same to go for something based on your analysis and requirements of yours. Hope you get it.
More Resources
Umbrella Stroller Vs Regular Stroller
My name is Olivia Brown, and I’m a New York-based blogger and stay-at-home parent. Former business executive enjoying retirement and time with kids Lily and Max. On my blog, I review things for kids and offer my honest thoughts and insights to other parents who may be having the same or similar experiences.
